I owned one and test drove the other several times. The deciding factor for me was comfort during long drives. After a few hours on the highway, one simply felt less tiring and the seats were better. I don't think you can go wrong with either, but I'd buy the one I chose again.

My experience was the opposite. I looked at both, compared insurance quotes, maintenance costs and resale value. The numbers pushed me toward the other option. Sometimes the best car isn't the one with the nicest brochure, it's the one that costs less to own over five years.

I'd recommend driving both back-to-back. Reviews only tell part of the story. I was convinced I wanted one model until I sat in it and realized I preferred the visibility, controls and overall feel of the competitor. Personal preference matters more than people admit.